Voltaire on the Quakers: Philosophical Roots of Tolerance
Imagine stepping ashore in England in 1726 as a French writer, fresh from exile and the shadow of the Bastille, only to have your very first encounter be with a Quaker who refuses to remove his hat in your presence. No bow, no title — just a plain “thou.” For Voltaire, this moment was far more than a cultural oddity. It marked the beginning of a philosophical quest into the foundations of tolerance, one he would later weave into his celebrated Letters on the English. But what intellectual traditions shaped the lens through which he viewed this remarkable religious community? The Legacy of Skepticism When Voltaire composed his first letter on the Quakers, he was drawing from a deep well of philosophical skepticism. Two centuries earlier, Michel de Montaigne had already posed the essential question: who are we to pass judgment on the customs of others? In his famous essay on cannibals, Montaigne demonstrated how seemingly strange practices reveal their own internal logic upon closer inspection. Voltaire applied precisely this method to the Quakers. Rather than dismissing their refusal to swear oaths, their rejection of ecclesiastical hierarchy, or their austere dress as foolishness, he presented these as elements of a […]