Montaigne on Envoys: When Obedience Falls Short
What happens when a messenger carries out his orders to the letter, without stopping to consider whether circumstances have changed? Michel de Montaigne poses this question in his brief but provocative essay ‘On the Custom of Some Ambassadors.’ His answer touches on a fundamental tension that resonates deeply within Freemasonry: the balance between obedience and personal judgment. What Is This Essay Really About? In the sixteenth essay of Book One of his Essays, Montaigne examines the role of envoys and ambassadors in diplomatic missions. Though it is one of his shorter reflections, the central question is far from simple. Montaigne asks to what extent an envoy has the right — or even the duty — to deviate from his literal instructions when the situation demands it. Should a messenger obey blindly, or should he use his own insight to better serve the intentions of the one who sent him? The essay was written in an age when diplomacy was a perilous affair. Communication was slow, decisions often had to be made on the spot, and a single miscalculation could mean the difference between war and peace. Montaigne knew this world from the inside. As a former mayor of Bordeaux and […]