zero-sum thinking Archieven - De Vrijmetselaar

Antique bronze balance scales symbolizing profit and loss in Masonic philosophy

Montaigne on Profit and Loss: Beyond the Masonic Path

A pair of bronze scales, joined at a central pivot point. When one side descends, the other rises. This everyday object — once found in every market hall and apothecary shop — became for Michel de Montaigne the symbol of a disturbing truth about human exchange. In his short but powerful essay ‘That the Profit of One Man Is the Damage of Another,’ the sixteenth-century philosopher forces us to ask whether human dealings can ever be truly reciprocal. For Freemasons, who place brotherhood and connection at the heart of their craft, this essay opens a profound reflection on the nature of genuine community. The Scales as a Mirror of Existence Montaigne opens his essay by referencing the Athenian lawgiver Solon, who — according to Demades — argued that no profit is possible without a corresponding loss elsewhere. The scales serve here not merely as a measuring device but as a metaphor for the human condition. Every transaction, every exchange, every acquisition seems inevitably tied to a loss on the other side. Montaigne cites the Roman poet Lucretius, who described how nature itself operates on this very principle: what grows does so at the expense of something else that perishes. This […]

Open book with Montaigne's essays beside Masonic building tools and rough ashlar

Montaigne on Profit and Loss: Dissecting Zero-Sum Thinking

Have you ever wondered whether your success automatically means someone else loses out? It’s a deeply ingrained assumption in our culture — the idea that the world is a fixed pie, and every slice you take leaves less for everyone else. Michel de Montaigne, the sixteenth-century French philosopher and father of the personal essay, examined precisely this assumption in one of his shortest yet most provocative pieces of writing. Centuries later, his reflections still challenge the way we think about wealth, value, and what it truly means to build something together. The Heart of the Essay In Essay 21 of the first book of his Essais, Montaigne investigates the ancient belief that profit and loss are always perfectly balanced. The title says it all: “That the profit of one man is the damage of another.” He opens with a reference to Demades, an Athenian orator who condemned a trader on the grounds that his profession could only be profitable at the expense of others. This classical conviction serves as Montaigne’s launching point for deeper reflection. The essay is remarkably brief — even by Montaigne’s own standards. Yet within its compact frame, it delivers a fundamental critique of the economic thinking […]